Main engine fire from a loose two-screw fuel flange (Stena Europe)
EL-0119 · Solved · rating 0 · occurred 11 Feb 2023
Source: /cases/el-0119
What happened#
Ro-ro ferry, four Wärtsilä Vasa 32 main engines. ME3 was started for arrival in port. Thirteen minutes later the ECR got a low fuel pressure alarm on the port fuel system, the standby fuel pump cut in, and one minute after that the fire alarms went off in the port engine room and the funnel casing.
Fuel sprayed from a low-pressure fuel joint (7 bar) at the free end of ME3 onto the exhaust manifold (> 400 °C). The water mist system knocked down most of the fire; the crew finished it with hoses. Nobody was hurt, but ME3 was out of service for three months.
Diagnosis#
- The leak came from a two-screw flange on the external fuel pipe between the A and B banks. One screw was missing and the O-ring was pushed out of its groove.
- The same flange had sprayed fuel two weeks earlier. The engineer stopped the engine, renewed the O-ring and screws, and put it back in service.
- The joint had no anti-spray tape, and the shielding around it was incomplete.
- The insulation behind the B6 cylinder head was displaced, which left the exhaust manifold bare.
Root cause#
Two-screw flanges screw into blind threads. Vibration and fretting wear those threads, the screws lose clamping force, and fuel pressure pushes the O-ring out. Wärtsilä warned about this in 1995 and offered a class-approved four-screw flange kit. The ship had fitted it on only one engine out of four. The company did not know about the bulletin.
The second cause was hot surfaces. After the fire the company re-lagged everything and checked it with a spot IR thermometer. Two months later MAIB inspectors with a thermal camera found surfaces above 220 °C on every running engine, some above 400 °C.
Timeline / response#
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| 21:01 | ME3 started and clutched in for arrival. |
| 21:14 | Low fuel pressure alarm, standby fuel pump starts. |
| 21:15 | Fire and smoke detectors alarm in the port ER and funnel casing. |
| 21:16 | Fire seen at the front of ME3. Water mist started, ME3 stopped, fuel pump stopped. |
| — | Remote quick-closing valves tripped from the bridge. All engines lose fuel. |
| — | Fire out. QCVs reset for ME1, ME2 and ME4. |
| 22:37 | Berthed using ME1 and ME2. |
Lessons#
- A joint that has leaked once will leak again. Find out why it leaked before you put the engine back on line. Renewing the O-ring is not enough.
- Read your engine maker's service letters. Make sure someone in the office gets them. Many old fuel-leak fixes already exist.
- Use a thermal camera, not a spot thermometer. A spot reading misses the gap between two insulation pads. Look for anything above
220 °Cnear fuel or lube oil pipes. - Anti-spray tape on every low-pressure fuel joint and the shielding complete, including after maintenance.
- Don't go into a fire space without BA, even when the fire looks small.
Source: MAIB report 20/2024 — Engine room fire on board ro-ro passenger ferry Stena Europe. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.