Volvo Penta D16: con-rods through crankcase from swapped big-end caps (Wight Sky)

Main EnginePropulsion & ThrustersFire & SafetyVolvo Penta D16 MHME2 low LO pressure shutdown; ME4 common alarm

Contents
  1. What happened
  2. Diagnosis
  3. Root cause
  4. Timeline / response
  5. Lessons
  6. Comments · 0

What happened#

Ro-ro ferry with four Volvo Penta D16 MH high-speed MEs; one or two drive each Voith Schneider unit through fluid couplings. Wight Sky had three catastrophic ME failures in 15 months. The 2017 one caused a fire that seriously injured an engineer.

In August 2018 ME2 (new, 2241 h) lost LO pressure running in parallel with ME1. One minute after the ECU started a shutdown, No.4 con-rod came out through the crankcase and oil mist ignited. In December 2018 ME4, also new, with only 389 h, threw its No.4 con-rod through the crankcase about 50 m from the berth at Lymington.

Hole in the ME2 crankcase at No.4, with the ejected con-rod. Photo: MAIB
Hole in the ME2 crankcase at No.4, with the ejected con-rod. Photo: MAIB

Diagnosis#

  • ME4: big-end caps No.4 and No.5 swapped at factory build (serial numbers did not match). No.4 cap bolts failed in tension. No.5 bolt torque was below spec, with clear fretting on the rod/cap faces.
  • ME2: No.5 main shells had turned 180° and blocked oil to No.5 main and No.4 crankpin. Particles consistent with casting sand (~190 µm) were embedded in the shells.
  • The 2017 rebuilt ME2 had crank-polishing abrasives in its oilways, probably not cleaned out.
  • Sister ship Wight Light's ME1 seized 700 h after overhaul: main caps 1 and 7 swapped.
  • A modified duplex filter changeover cock gave about 1 bar LO pressure drop at full speed. The filter bypass valve opened slightly and passed 10–20 % unfiltered oil.
  • ME2 sat on old mounts, two in newly drilled bedplate holes. Over about 1400 h it vibrated enough to break air cooler brackets, until new mounts went into the original holes.
  • With two engines on one VSP, the shutdown engine took about 30 s to declutch and was still driven.
Matched cap and rod serial numbers. Photo: MAIB
Matched cap and rod serial numbers. Photo: MAIB

Root cause#

D16 rods are fracture-split, so each cap fits only its own rod. A swapped cap has less contact, the joint frets, bolt tension drops and the bolts fail.

ME2 lost oil to the turned main shells. Poor combustion, abrasives, misalignment, vibration and contaminated oil might all have contributed. The filter bypass also raised bearing wear risk. Behind the fleet's record: build and overhaul checks too weak to catch assembly errors, and poor oil and coolant monitoring. Single ME failures were not raised as SMS non-conformities because redundancy kept the ferry running.

Timeline / response#

TimeEvent
26 Aug 18:40:52ME2 LO pressure loss, shutdown starts.
18:41:55No.4 con-rod through crankcase, fireball.
—Master sees fire on CCTV, confirms declutch, releases water mist.
19:11Berthed at Yarmouth.
14 Dec 06:55:48ME4 common alarm, ~50 m from berth. LO pressure low but within alarm limits.
06:57:56ME4 MODBUS alarm, banging, smoke.
06:58:51Aft ER water mist. QCVs tripped.
—ME4 still running; declutched and stopped from bridge.

Lessons#

  1. Check matched serial numbers before torquing. Rod and cap must match; main caps must match their position.
  2. Clean oilways before first start, especially after crank polishing.
  3. Know your LO filter bypass. Log LO pressure at full speed after any filter block change. Apply maker bulletins (here: new overflow valve spring, cock removed).
  4. Trend LO and coolant analysis. Label samples fully (engine and oil) so Volvo Penta's stricter criteria apply. After a bad result, resample every 100 h.
  5. After an engine change, check alignment and mounts. Use the original bolt holes; investigate new vibration.
  6. Time your shutdown-to-declutch, and restrict entry to the ER while the MEs are running.

Treat every ME failure as an SMS non-conformity, even when redundancy keeps you running.

Source: MAIB report 4/2022 — Two catastrophic engine failures, one resulting in a fire, on board ro-ro passenger ferry Wight Sky. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in