MAN 48/60: con-rod small end breaks after bad bush renewal (Finlandia Seaways)
EL-0120 · Solved · rating 0 · occurred 16 Apr 2018
Source: /cases/el-0120
What happened#
Ro-ro at sea, single MAN 12V48/60 at 500 rpm, 110 662 running hours. The on-watch 3/E was in the purifier room when he heard loud metallic knocking. The bridge felt heavy vibration and saw pitch and speed gauges swinging.
Within seconds there was a bang. A5 and B5 connecting rods and the B5 piston went through the side of the crankcase, hot oil vapour caught fire, and the ship blacked out. The 3/E escaped through thick smoke by the aft escape route. He had no EEBD, and he fell off the first vertical ladder three times. He was flown to hospital with lung, kidney and eye injuries and recovered. The crew sealed the ER and released CO₂. The fire was out within 20 minutes.
Diagnosis#
- Alarm order: crankcase oil mist high, then No. 6 main bearing temp high and splash oil monitor failure. The standby LO pump started within 2 s. The crankcase relief doors did not open. This was a sudden mechanical break, not a crankcase explosion or slow wear.
- The upper half of the A5 piston was still in its liner with the pin in place. The A5 con-rod had broken at the small end eye.
- The fracture face showed beach marks: a fatigue crack that started at the bush contact surface and grew outwards.
- MAN checked the other 10 small ends: 7 had cuts or notches on the bore, typical of a disc cutter or angle grinder used to get the old bush out. Small ends from the sister ship also showed heat marks from a torch.
Root cause#
The piston pin bushes were renewed by a shore contractor, but not the way MAN specifies. MAN's method is to mill a groove along the inside of the old bush, leaving under 0.5 mm, so it collapses and comes out. The new bush is then shrunk in liquid nitrogen (−195 °C). The contractor cut the bush out with a disc cutter and probably used heat. The cuts went into the shot-peened bore of the small end. Each notch is a stress raiser, and at 500 rpm the crack grew until the eye broke after about 90 000 hours, well short of what these rods normally do.
Nobody saw the notches as a problem, although they were visible by eye. Class was never told that small ends had been swapped or were past MAN's recommended hours.
Timeline / response#
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| ~20:00 | 3/E starts rounds. Knocking heard, vibration felt on the bridge. Pitch cut 60 % → 25 %. |
| 20:03 | Bang, flames past the purifier room door, blackout. Emergency generator starts. |
| — | Master puts pitch to zero, general alarm. C/E finds the ER full of smoke and trips the fuel QCVs and pump emergency stops. |
| — | 3/E escapes by the aft emergency route. Muster complete. |
| by ~20:23 | ER sealed and CO₂ released. Fire out. |
Lessons#
- Small end bushes are a workshop job. Use the maker's method: mill, never grind or burn, and nitrogen-shrink the new bush. Ask the contractor how they do it, and ask for proof.
- Inspect every con-rod that comes back from overhaul. Any cut, notch or heat colour in the bore means reject it.
- Keep a record for each con-rod and small end: serial number, hours, who overhauled it. Don't swap parts between ships without telling class.
- Heavy knocking plus an oil mist alarm: stop the engine now and keep clear of the crankcase doors.
- EEBDs along every escape route, including the secondary one. Practise using that route in smoke.
Source: MAIB report 2/2021 — Engine failure and subsequent fire on ro-ro cargo vessel Finlandia Seaways. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.