Main engine fuel filters burst with both return valves shut (Sandy Ground)
EL-0131 · Solved · rating 0 · occurred 22 Dec 2022
Source: /cases/el-0131
What happened#
Staten Island ferry, four EMD MEs at 92 % load, 884 people on board. The oilers spent over 40 minutes turning valves to balance the two FO day tanks. In the end, the NTSB concluded, both FO return isolation ball valves at the day tanks were closed.
Five minutes after leaving Manhattan, all four MEs alarmed at once: high fuel filter dP, then low fuel pressure two seconds later. The spin-on fuel filters had burst. Fuel from ME1 sprayed onto ME2's exhaust manifold and caught fire. Novec put it out. The ship lost all power and was towed in. No injuries; repairs cost $12.7 million.
Diagnosis#
- FO supply pressure, normally
87–92 psi(~6 bar), jumped to148 psi(~10 bar), the sensor maximum, on all four engines at the same time. - The duplex spin-on filters were distorted at the sealing face on all four MEs. On ME1 the gasket was blown out, pointing toward ME2.
- Check valves, return piping and tanks were clear. The closed return valves were the only possible blockage.
- Each engine's filter manifold block had a
120 psi(~8 bar) relief valve, but it was piped into the common return line, before the closed valves. - Fuel hit ME2's exhaust manifold between the joints of the insulation blankets (logged exhaust
624–942 °F,~330–505 °C).
Root cause#
The engine-driven fuel pumps are positive displacement: at a given engine speed they deliver a fixed flow, whatever the pressure. With both return valves shut, excess fuel had nowhere to go and pressure rose. The relief valve discharged into the same blocked line, so the filter seals failed first.
The return valves were fitted a month before entry into service, so crews could balance day tanks by throttling the returns. No relief valve was added, although the engine maker says returns should go to the tank without shutoff valves. No training followed. Older ferries in the fleet had relief valves that bypassed the return valves, so the crew likely expected the system could not be overpressurized.
Timeline / response#
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| 16:00 | Difference about 550 gal. |
| 16:12–16:13 | Both day tank low-level alarms disabled. |
| 16:47 | High filter dP, then low fuel pressure 2 s later, on all four MEs. CCTV shows fuel dripping onto ME2; spraying soon after. |
| — | Fire alarm about 1 min later. |
| 16:54 | Fire on ME2 exhaust manifold. MEs alarm "common engine shutdown". |
| 16:56 | ME4 shaft stops. Propulsion lost (generators still running). |
| — | After the ship stops, both anchors let go. |
| 16:58 | ER fans and dampers closed. Both fuel QCVs closed; generators stop. Emergency generator starts. |
| ~17:00 | Emergency generator shuts down (fire-damaged cable blew a control fuse). Blackout. |
| — | Novec released manually, with the master's permission. |
Lessons#
Never block the fuel return from an engine with a positive-displacement fuel pump.
- Trace where your relief valves go. A relief into the common return gives no protection when that line is shut.
- Treat day tank return valves as always open. If a shutoff in the return is needed, fit a relief valve that bypasses it to a service tank. Sandy Ground now has
4 psireliefs at each day tank. - Balance day tanks with the purifier discharge (fill) valves, not the returns.
- Retrain after every fuel system change. Crews from older ships may expect a relief valve that isn't there.
- Stop the engines at once on filter dP plus low fuel pressure with fuel spraying. Check the shaft has actually stopped.
- Don't disable day tank level alarms as nuisances.
Source: NTSB report MIR-24-17 — Engine Room Fire on board Passenger Ferry Sandy Ground.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.