Aux boiler explosion: waxy MGO, then fan restart into a gassy furnace (Manhattan Bridge)

Boiler""Aux boiler emergency trip (Furnace flame-eye abnormal)

Contents
  1. What happened
  2. Diagnosis
  3. Root cause
  4. Timeline / response
  5. Lessons
  6. Comments · 0

What happened#

A 13,900 TEU container ship was berthing at Felixstowe in winter. The auxiliary boiler (rotary cup burner) had been on MGO for three days for the ECA. It tripped four times between 17:30 and 19:51. The first time the rotary cup was cleaned; then it was just reset.

At 23:01 it tripped on Furnace (Flame-Eye) Abnormal: flame after the burner stopped. The trip stopped the burner, FD fan, secondary damper and FO pump. The 2/E reset it and the alarm came back. He saw no flame or leak, so he switched to Manual to purge and the FD fan started. He saw flame, closed the QCV and tried to stop the fan, but the furnace exploded. The secondary air nozzle hit the oiler in front of the burner and killed him. The 2/E was burned.

After the blast: the burner unit door lies on the deck and its hinge has failed. Photo: MAIB
After the blast: the burner unit door lies on the deck and its hinge has failed. Photo: MAIB

Diagnosis#

  • Trial at Hamburg after repair (24 Jan, air about 0 °C): strainers almost clogged with slimy wax. FO pressure fell from 0.3 to about 0.15 MPa within a minute, with no alarm.
  • MGO: CFPP 12 °C (JTSB) / 14 °C (MAIB), cloud point 19 °C, pour point about -10 °C. The bunker report gave only pour point.
  • Outside air 4–6 °C; a deckhead ER vent blew it onto the burner. Burner area about 12–15 °C, below the CFPP.
  • FO low-pressure setting 0.15 MPa; pressure stayed above it, so firing carried on while lean.
  • Cold flow improver was on board, unused. With it CFPP was about 5 °C; 0.3 MPa held only after it was added and the pressure adjusting valve readjusted.
Waxy deposits in the boiler fuel line filter, enough to restrict fuel flow. Photo: MAIB
Waxy deposits in the boiler fuel line filter, enough to restrict fuel flow. Photo: MAIB

Root cause#

Wax came out of the cold MGO and clogged the strainers (and probably upset the pressure adjusting valve). The burner fired lean with full air, leaving unburnt MGO in the furnace that kept burning after it stopped. The trip closed the damper, so the hot furnace held flame plus CO and/or MGO vapour. The FD fan then sent air in. JTSB thinks it somewhat likely this gave a CO backdraft (the maker's view) or MGO vapour diluted into its explosive range (0.7–5.0 %).

Behind this: the fuel was tested for pour point only. Afterwards the maker allowed reset only with the switch at Stop and added an interlock after repeated trips.

Timeline / response#

TimeEvent
16 Jan 14:35Changed from HFO to MGO for the ECA.
19 Jan 17:30–19:51Four trips, reset each time.
22:45First line ashore.
23:01Flame-eye abnormal trip. Reset, alarm again.
—Manual purge, FD fan starts, QCV closed.
about 23:04Furnace explosion.

Lessons#

  1. Test MGO for cloud point and CFPP, not just pour point. Keep it above both in cold areas. Use cold flow improver only per supplier/manager instructions; MAIB treats it as a last resort.
  2. Watch the strainer in cold weather. Trend FO pressure. The manager (with the maker) raised the low-pressure trip from 0.15 to 0.2–0.24 MPa, sensed after the main solenoid valves. Check the pressure adjusting valve holds 0.3 MPa on MGO.
  3. Repeated trips mean a fault. Find the cause before you relight.
  4. Do not start the FD fan to "purge" a furnace that may hold flame, CO or fuel vapour. Keep the secondary damper open after a burner stop so the furnace keeps ventilating; it now opens automatically.
  5. Stay clear of the burner door during resets.

Flame in a stopped, closed-up furnace: shut the fuel, do not start the fan, keep clear of the burner door.

Source: JTSB report MA2017-12 (via MAIB) and MAIB Safety Bulletin SB1/2017. MAIB material and photos: Crown copyright, licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in