Engine room fire: fuel backflow through an open return line (Scot Stuttgart)
EL-0132 · Solved · rating 0 · occurred 17 May 2025
Source: /cases/el-0132
What happened#
Chemical tanker with two engine rooms, alongside in San Juan discharging cargo. The port AE was under LOTO for turbocharger and aftercooler cleaning. The crew removed the aftercooler and the fuel return tubing. All day the DO purifier kept filling the port DO day tank.
At 04:29 the fire alarm went off. Thick white smoke came from the port ER into the ECR. The crew shut down the port ER and released half the CO2. After shore firefighters ventilated the space, the smoke turned black and the rest was released. No injuries.
Diagnosis#
- Fuel in the AE skid, on the main deck and down the aft ladder to the second deck.
- Fuel was still dripping from the open port where the return tubing had been removed.
- The AE fuel return line entered the top of the day tank with no check valve. The open tubing was not isolated or capped during the work.
- Purifier output to the day tank: about
320 L/h(85 gal/h). - Below the skid, on the second deck: the start air compressor control panel (
400 V, live from the emergency switchboard) and economizer thermal oil lines (180–200 °C). - Panel: arc-flash pattern, diesel marks, melted parts, feeder breaker tripped.
Root cause#
As the purifier filled the day tank, the level rose to the return line inlet. Diesel then flowed backwards out of the open port on the engine, filled the skid and dripped through the gratings. It ignited from an arc in the live panel or on the thermal oil lines (diesel autoignition about 210 °C; splashed fuel ignites lower).
The LOTO checklist items "check drawings" and "isolate valves" were ticked, but the return line was not isolated. The drawing shows a clear backflow path.
Timeline / response#
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| 13:00 (day before) | LOTO permit for port AE maintenance. |
| ~22:30 (day before) | Routine round. Nothing found. |
| 04:29 | Fire alarm. Smoke in port ER. Everything stopped, QCVs closed. |
| 04:38 | 7 of 14 CO2 bottles released. |
| 05:20 | Shore fire brigade on scene. |
| 05:41 | Fire chief asks to enter; master agrees. Fuel found on deck, 304 °C near the AE. |
| 06:20 | Extraction fans started. Smoke turns black. Space sealed again. |
| 06:58 | Remaining 7 CO2 bottles released. |
| ~07:45 | Hot spots put out. ER sealed for 24 h. |
Lessons#
- Trace return lines too. Before opening a fuel, LO or hydraulic line, follow the whole system on the drawing. A return into the top of a filling tank runs backwards once the level reaches its inlet.
- Blank or cap every open fuel connection on an engine under maintenance, supply and return. Remove the blanks before start-up.
- Check your AE return line has a check valve at the day tank. Other ships in this fleet had one; this ship and one sister did not. The company has now fitted them.
- Watch the day tank level while a consumer's return line is open. Here the purifier kept filling a tank that also fed the running port ME. Isolate or cap the line instead.
- Look under the skid and gratings. Know what is below: live panels, thermal oil, exhaust lines.
- Write each isolation point on the LOTO permit from the drawing, supply and return, by valve or blank. If a line has no valve, write how you will blank it.
Release the full designed CO2 charge for the space. Keep it sealed until the fire is smothered and cooled, up to
24 h. Here, ventilating the space about an hour after the first release likely fed a smouldering fire.
Source: NTSB report MIR-26-29 — Engine Room Fire aboard Chemical Tanker Scot Stuttgart.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.