Generator engine fails on non-OEM bearings run to OEM intervals (Kommandor Susan)

Auxiliary EngineElectricalDeck MachineryCaterpillar 3516B-TAER fire alarm, blackout

Contents
  1. What happened
  2. Diagnosis
  3. Root cause
  4. Timeline / response
  5. Lessons
  6. Comments · 0

What happened#

Diesel-electric vessel on sea trials, just out of the lock at Leith with a pilot on board. DG1 and DG4 were on line. The C/E heard a change in engine note on one generator, then a loud bang. The fire alarm went off and the ER filled with smoke and oil mist.

The 2/E stopped both DGs from the ECR, which meant blackout and no propulsion. The emergency generator took the essential loads. A fire team with dry powder put out small oil fires in the bilges around DG1. The ship drifted east with the tide, and the anchors couldn't be let go: both windlasses were clutched in to their electric motors, and the clutches can't be released without power. A tug made fast after about 70 minutes, DG4 was restarted, and the ship returned to port. No injuries.

Diagnosis#

  • DG1, cylinders 5 and 6: pistons broken, con-rods free of the crankshaft and through both sides of the crankcase. The big end and small end bearings were worn away and heat-damaged.
  • The Caterpillar dealer stripped the engine. Pistons, con-rods, big end, small end and main bearings were all non-OEM (Costex Tractor Parts, not class-approved). These parts had been fitted at the 2019 overhaul.
  • Genuine big end shells have an aluminium backing layer under the white metal. These had a copper layer, and it was poorly bonded.
  • Most likely sequence: No. 5 big end bearing ran out, then it was hammered thin, then the No. 5 cap broke. The rod damaged the counterweight and liners, piston 6 seized, and the No. 6 rod bolts failed from overload.
  • Oil analysis 19 days (127 h) earlier showed no significant wear metals.

Root cause#

Caterpillar had extended the major overhaul interval to 24 000 h, but only for engines with genuine parts. The overhaul yard fitted replacement parts. The owner at the time didn't check, so the next owner never knew. Copy bearings, designed for the standard interval, were running on the extended one. DG1 failed after 13 466 h.

The anchors were a second problem. The anchoring procedure didn't consider a total loss of power.

Timeline / response#

TimeEvent
10:20DG1 and DG4 started to warm through.
12:52Clears the lock into the Firth of Forth.
13:05Change in engine note, bang, fire alarm. ER full of smoke and oil mist.
13:06Bridge informed. Both DGs stopped. Blackout, emergency generator on.
—Muster. Fire team puts out burning oil around DG1 with dry powder. Anchors can't be released.
14:16Tug fast. DG4 restarted, limited propulsion back, windlass clutches released.
18:06Alongside in Leith.

Lessons#

  1. An extended overhaul interval is only valid with genuine parts. If you don't know what's inside the engine, go back to the standard interval.
  2. At overhaul, ask for the parts' origin and certificates, and keep them with the engine records. Pass them on when the ship is sold.
  3. A new owner should ask what was fitted at the last overhaul. Don't assume.
  4. Oil analysis won't always warn you. A sudden change in engine note or a knock means stop and investigate.
  5. Keep windlass clutches out when the windlasses aren't in use, especially in pilotage waters, so you can drop the anchor on the brake in a blackout.

Source: MAIB report 10/2026 — Catastrophic engine failure and subsequent fire on board the site investigation vessel Kommandor Susan. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in