Aux engine room fire: slipped fuel pump coupling and exhaust leak (Finnmaster)
EL-0121 · Solved · rating 0 · occurred 19 Sept 2021
Source: /cases/el-0121
What happened#
Ro-ro leaving Hull with a pilot on board. AE1 had just been paralleled with AE2. Eight minutes after leaving the berth, smoke was detected in the aux engine room. Both AE2 exhaust temperature gauges were off the scale (> 650 °C), and a fire then started under AE2's outboard turbocharger.
Portable extinguishers didn't work. AE2 was stopped, then AE1 stopped as well and the ship blacked out. The emergency generator started but did not close onto the emergency switchboard. The crew released CO₂, but only half of the cylinders opened. The ship drifted in the dock until tugs got it back alongside. The fire was later put out. No injuries.
Diagnosis#
The fire came from a chain of three faults:
- Fuel pump coupling slipped. A bolt in the inboard fuel injection pump drive coupling failed from fatigue, and the second bolt's nut came off. The coupling turned about 17°, which retarded injection about 34° on the inboard bank (to about 12° after TDC). Fuel burned late, in the exhaust. The governor added fuel, so both banks ran hot. No alarm or trip: the engine still carried its load.
- Exhaust joint leaked. At the last overhaul a contractor had assembled the turbocharger outlet transition ring with sealing compound, which is not the maker's method. Hot exhaust gas escaped into the insulated box and out through a gap at the flywheel casing.
- The flexible hose cooked. A small-bore flexible fuel hose to the instrument panel ran right by that gap. It was part of an alarm-system modification from before 2006 that class never approved. It was over 1.5 m long, had no isolation valve, and the fuel in it was static, so nothing cooled it. It failed and sprayed fuel onto the hot exhaust.
Why the fire-fighting systems let the crew down:
- CO₂: one flexible pilot hose coupling had never been fully drilled at the factory and was blocked. There were also leaks at 12 pilot hose connections. The service in March 2021 had not tested the pilot line properly.
- Emergency generator: a latent fault in its circuit breaker. Routine tests never caught it.
Root cause#
Known weak points that nobody reported or fixed: this coupling had failed before (2018), and the crew had started using thread-locker on it, which is against the maker's instructions. Add contractor work nobody checked and an unapproved hose in the hottest spot on the engine. No single check would have caught it: the engine gave no alarm until the fire.
Timeline / response#
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| 19:20 | AE1 started and paralleled with AE2. Routine walk-round, nothing seen. |
| 20:05 | Departs berth. |
| 20:13 | Smoke alarm in the aux ER. AE2 exhaust temperatures off scale. Fire starts at AE2's outboard turbocharger. |
| — | CO₂ and dry powder extinguishers used, without success. AE2 stopped. |
| 20:17 | AE1 stops. Blackout. EDG runs but its breaker doesn't close. |
| 20:21 | CO₂ released. Only half the cylinders discharge. |
| — | Tugs re-berth the ship. Fire later extinguished. |
Lessons#
- Exhaust temperature spread on a medium-speed engine with no other alarm? Think injection timing. Check the fuel pump drive coupling bolts, nuts and witness marks.
- A coupling or bolt that has failed once is a design or procedure problem. Report it to the office and the maker. Don't fix it with thread-locker.
- Walk your engines looking for flexible hoses carrying fuel or oil. For each one check: approved type, as short as possible, away from the exhaust, with an isolation valve.
- Watch contractors at major overhauls. Ask how each joint is being made up.
- CO₂ system: after every service, prove the whole pilot line works, not just the cylinders.
- Test the emergency generator on load, through its own breaker, so you know it will actually feed the emergency switchboard.
Source: MAIB report 13/2025 — Auxiliary engine room fire on board the ro-ro cargo ship Finnmaster and MAIB safety bulletins 1/2022 and 1/2023. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.