Engine room flooding from a corroded sea water pipe at the strainer (Oliver Hazard Perry)

Auxiliary EngineOWS & BilgeElectricalPumpsJohn Deere diesel generatorAC power fault alarm on fire alarm panel, blackout

Contents
  1. What happened
  2. Diagnosis
  3. Root cause
  4. Timeline / response
  5. Lessons
  6. Comments · 0

What happened#

Sail training tall ship (128 ft), two Caterpillar C12 propulsion engines, two John Deere DGs (99 kW). Moored, one crewmember on board. Shore power breakers kept tripping, so the port DG ran overnight, cooled by its engine-driven SW pump. At 2100 the ER and the auxiliary machinery space (AMS) forward of it were in order.

Overnight the 2 in SW pipe to the port DG broke at the bronze strainer. The pump fed the break until, most likely, water shorted connections, tripped the DG and blacked out the ship. At 0735 the crewmember woke to a power fault alarm; he did not report hearing any bilge alarm. The ER was flooded and the AMS had about 1 ft of water behind the dogged watertight door. About 21 000 US gal was pumped out.

Diagnosis#

  • Water covered the main engines and reduction gears; both DGs and the emergency generator partly submerged.
  • Alarm panel logged power loss at 0530. Flooding likely began about 2200.
  • With the DG stopped, the ER still rose about 1 in/h and the AMS 0.5 in/h, then 2 in/h once the ER reached about 3 ft.
  • Seawater was seen leaking through the closed watertight door into the AMS.
  • Starboard DG SW nipple and valve replaced a year earlier; the removed valve showed similar corrosion.
  • Bilge alarms last tested July 2024, 10 months before. No alarm panel or repeater in the accommodation.
Port DG seawater supply pipe broken at its threaded joint with the bronze strainer. Photo: US Coast Guard
Port DG seawater supply pipe broken at its threaded joint with the bronze strainer. Photo: US Coast Guard

Root cause#

Threading thins the wall of steel pipe, so less corrosion is needed to break it. The threaded steel pipe corroded and broke at the bronze strainer inlet. Vibration or galvanic action between dissimilar metals are typical causes; NTSB did not say which applied. The cathodic protection system was working.

The port side was not renewed after the starboard repair; there was no dedicated engineer since. The watertight bulkhead and door did not stop progressive flooding. The leak path was not found: possibly poor gasket contact with the knife edge, or pass-through fittings not resealed.

Timeline / response#

TimeEvent
2100 May 10Round of ER and AMS, all in order.
~2200 May 10Flooding most likely starts. Port DG running.
0530 May 11Alarm panel logs power loss. Blackout.
0735Crewmember finds ER and AMS flooded.
0810Fire brigade on board.
1030Diver plugs ER hull openings.
1715Pumping out starts.
1145 May 12Pumping complete, vessel dewatered.

Lessons#

  1. Treat threaded steel pipe at bronze fittings as weak points. Inspect and renew these joints; working cathodic protection did not save this one.
  2. Found corrosion on one side? Renew the other side too.
  3. A running DG keeps its SW pump feeding any break. Here flooding slowed only after the blackout stopped it. If a DG runs overnight, make night ER rounds.
  4. Test bilge high-level sensors monthly and check the alarm is heard in the cabins. With reduced manning, fit an accommodation repeater.
  5. Know where the hull plugs are. Bilge pumps and all power were lost; a diver closed the openings with wooden plugs from the damage control kit.
  6. Check that watertight door gaskets make full contact with the knife edge, and reseal any bulkhead pass-through fitting disturbed during work.

Source: NTSB report MIR-26-09 — Engine Room Flooding aboard Sailing School Vessel Oliver Hazard Perry.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in