Log inJoin

MAN B&W ME: "Large deviation from model curve" alarm, worn HPS valves suspected

Main EngineMAN B&W ME (electronic engine), exact model not statedLarge deviation from model curve

Contents
  1. Symptoms
  2. Checked
  3. Diagnosis
  4. Fix
  5. Result
  6. Answers · 0

Symptoms#

The "Large deviation from model curve" alarm on a MAN B&W ME engine most often points to a worn or defective proportional valve on an HPS pump. That is my working suspicion for the alarm on our engine; it is not confirmed.

  • Our main engine is a MAN B&W electronic (ME) type. It gave the alarm "Large deviation from model curve".
  • I took a screenshot of the alarm. It is not described here.

Checked#

CheckResult
Engine modelNot given
HPS pressures or other readingsNot given
Checks done on boardNot reported
Other hydraulic alarms at the same timeNot reported

Diagnosis#

The cause on our engine is not confirmed. From general experience, this alarm comes from the hydraulic power supply (HPS):

  • In most cases, the problem is a proportional valve on an HPS pump. One or more of these valves is worn or defective.
  • The alarm may reset with no repair done. Do not take this as a sign that all is well. A valve is probably worn, and the alarm will likely return.
  • A real mechanical fault inside an HPS pump is possible, but it does not happen often.
  • A hydraulic leak would normally give more alarms, not only this one.

Fix#

These are the steps I would take. They are not confirmed as the fix on our engine.

  1. From the MOP, download the HPS event records.
  2. Send them to MAN Energy Solutions for evaluation. This is the safest way to find the cause.
  3. If a proportional valve on an HPS pump is found worn, replace it.
  4. When the new valve is fitted, do a function test from the MOP.

Result#

I have no final result to report.

Answers · 0

No answers yet. Seen this before? Your reading could close it.

Seen this fault? Sign in to answer.Sign in