MAN B&W ME: "Large deviation from model curve" alarm, worn HPS valves suspected
EL-0140 · Open · rating 0 · occurred 27 Dec 2022
Source: /cases/el-0140
Symptoms#
The "Large deviation from model curve" alarm on a MAN B&W ME engine most often points to a worn or defective proportional valve on an HPS pump. That is my working suspicion for the alarm on our engine; it is not confirmed.
- Our main engine is a MAN B&W electronic (ME) type. It gave the alarm "Large deviation from model curve".
- I took a screenshot of the alarm. It is not described here.
Checked#
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Engine model | Not given |
| HPS pressures or other readings | Not given |
| Checks done on board | Not reported |
| Other hydraulic alarms at the same time | Not reported |
Diagnosis#
The cause on our engine is not confirmed. From general experience, this alarm comes from the hydraulic power supply (HPS):
- In most cases, the problem is a proportional valve on an HPS pump. One or more of these valves is worn or defective.
- The alarm may reset with no repair done. Do not take this as a sign that all is well. A valve is probably worn, and the alarm will likely return.
- A real mechanical fault inside an HPS pump is possible, but it does not happen often.
- A hydraulic leak would normally give more alarms, not only this one.
Fix#
These are the steps I would take. They are not confirmed as the fix on our engine.
- From the MOP, download the HPS event records.
- Send them to MAN Energy Solutions for evaluation. This is the safest way to find the cause.
- If a proportional valve on an HPS pump is found worn, replace it.
- When the new valve is fitted, do a function test from the MOP.
Result#
I have no final result to report.
Answers · 0
No answers yet. Seen this before? Your reading could close it.