Bunker fuel quality: ISO 8217 fuel can still cause engine problems
EL-0147 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 03 Sept 2024
Source: /cases/el-0147
Notes#
These are my general notes about bunker fuel quality. They do not describe a real fault on a ship. I give no engine maker, no readings and no test results. I wrote them in two parts.
Main point
Meeting ISO 8217 does not guarantee trouble-free fuel on board. In my experience, problems from contaminated fuel have become more common. The standard ISO 8217 tests may not find these problems. I link this to blending after the 2020 sulphur cap. Since then, suppliers mix new components into traditional fuels.
The main risk areas are:
- instability
- chemical contamination
- corrosive properties
- poor combustion
- cold flow
Cold regions
- Watch the pour point of HSFO, VLSFO and MGO.
- In 2023, pour point was the top cause of off-spec MGO. It was
36.6%of off-spec cases. - Keep the fuel at least
10 °Cabove its pour point.
Fuel properties and risks
1. Stability
- Unstable fuel makes sludge. Fuel can also become unstable in storage or when heated.
- Sludge blocks tanks, pipes, separators and filters.
- VLSFO is more paraffinic. Paraffins keep asphaltenes in solution less well than aromatics.
- The supplier must deliver stable fuel with a stability reserve.
2. Compatibility
- VLSFO from one region can be paraffinic. VLSFO from another region can be aromatic.
- Mixing the two can form sludge.
- Keep each bunker lot in its own tank where possible. Do not mix incompatible fuels.
3. Cold flow
- ISO 8217 sets a limit on pour point. But wax starts to form above the pour point.
- So compliant fuel can still block filters fast in cold areas.
- Paraffin can settle in tanks and reduce flow to the machinery.
- I think it is important to know the cold-flow properties of each bunkered fuel.
- Cold-flow additives only help if they go into the fuel before wax crystals form.
4. Acid number
- The fuel must contain no strong inorganic acids.
- A high acid number increases wear, mostly on fuel injection equipment.
- There is no accepted link between acid number and how corrosive a fuel is (ISO 8217:2017, appendix E).
5. Flashpoint
- Flashpoint shows the fire risk in storage.
- A tank kept below the flashpoint can still have flammable vapour above the fuel surface.
6. Ignition and combustion quality
- Poor ignition gives long combustion, slow pressure rise and low pmax.
- Unburnt fuel and soot then collect on the combustion chamber, exhaust valves, turbocharger, aftertreatment equipment and exhaust gas boiler / WHR.
- Long combustion can overheat the liner and break down the oil film. This leads to wear and scuffing. Fuel droplets can also hit the liner.
- Medium- and high-speed four-stroke engines are more sensitive than low-speed two-stroke engines.
- Signs: exhaust deposits, black smoke, knocking, trouble at low load.
- With delayed ignition, too much fuel burns at the same time. The sharp pressure rise damages rings and liners.
7. Cat fines
- Cat fines cause abrasive wear of liners, rings and injection equipment if the separators do not remove enough.
- Major engine makers recommend no more than
10 mg/kg(ppm) at engine inlet.
8. Low viscosity
- Below
2 cStat engine inlet, the oil film in the fuel pumps can break down and the pumps can seize. - Injection pressure can be too low. This gives problems at start and at low load.
- There may not be enough fuel index margin to accelerate.
- Supply, circulating, transfer and separator feed pumps also need more than
2 cSt. - Viscosity changes a lot with temperature. Control fuel temperature (cooling) with care.
9. Pour point
- Below the pour point, wax comes out of the fuel. It blocks filters and coats heat exchangers.
- In bad cases, wax builds up on the tank bottom and on heating coils. The coils can no longer heat the fuel. The fuel cannot be pumped out of the bunker tank.
10. Unusual blend components
| Component | Effect |
|---|---|
| Polymers (polystyrene, polyethylene, polypropylene) | Filter blocking |
| Polymethacrylates | Fuel pump sticking |
| Phenols (occasionally) | Filter blocking, pump sticking |
| Organic acids | Corrosion, pump sticking |
| Chlorinated hydrocarbons | Fuel pump seizure |
| Tall oils | Filter blocking |
| Estonian shale oil | Linked to heavy sludge in separators in earlier cases |
Regulation
On 2024-09-26, I added a regulatory update. An amendment to SOLAS II-2 Reg. 4 adds para 2.1.9. Under it, oil fuel delivered and used on board must not put the ship at risk. It must also not harm machinery performance or be a danger to personnel. It applies from 1 January 2026 (resolution MSC.550(108)).
References I named
- VPS article "Mitigating the risks of bad bunkers"
- MAN Energy Solutions Service Letter SL2014-593/DOJA (photo of waxy deposits in a fuel sample)
- IMO MSC 100/8/2 on safety issues with 2020-compliant fuels
Comments · 0
No comments yet.