Main engine piston crowns burnt: long low-load running and bad injectors

Main Engine

Contents
  1. Symptoms
  2. Checked
  3. Diagnosis
  4. Fix
  5. Result
  6. Comments · 0

Symptoms#

Burn marks on our main engine piston crowns came, as far as we can tell, from long running at low load together with faulty fuel injectors.

  • I found burn marks on the combustion side of the piston crowns.
  • I don't have the engine maker or model, the running hours, or which units had the marks.

Checked#

CheckResult
Look of the crown surfaceThis wear is known as "elephant skin" and is linked to high combustion temperature.
Engine load historyThe engine had run at low load for a long time. This later turned out to be one of the causes.
Main engine fuel injectorsFound faulty. I don't know what the fault was.
Reddish colour on the crownNot checked. It may simply be dye-check chemical, or copper from worn tubes in the main engine air cooler. Neither is confirmed.

Diagnosis#

We asked the engine maker to help with the investigation. In my view, the root cause appears to be long running at low load together with faulty main engine fuel injectors.

The low-load part works like this. During slow steaming, the turbocharger does not deliver enough scavenge air, so the blowers must work. The cylinders then get less air. Combustion becomes hotter and the exhaust gas gets hotter too. Over time, this heat can damage the crown surface.

Similar marks have also been seen on a crown after about 30,000 running hours, on the pump side and the exhaust side rather than directly below the injectors. On an engine with two injectors per cylinder, marks this far from the injectors point to other causes. I would check:

  • wear of the cylinder liner and the piston skirt;
  • misalignment of the running gear (piston, piston rod, crosshead and connecting rod) caused by liner or skirt wear, so the crown hits the liner wall and wears unevenly;
  • the piston cleaning ring: fitted in the wrong position after an overhaul, or not renewed when the liner was changed.

These faults usually also make a metallic noise while the engine runs. The cause in that second case is not known.

Fix#

The repair itself is not described here. What I can say:

  1. Investigate together with the engine maker.
  2. Deal with the faulty main engine fuel injectors. I don't know the type of fault or the work done.
  3. Avoid long periods at low load. A common rule is to raise the load above about 55% once every 48 running hours; most turbocharger makers are said to recommend something similar. I have not checked this against a maker document.
  4. If the marks are not below the injectors, check liner and skirt wear, running gear alignment, and the position and condition of the piston cleaning ring. These are suggestions only.

A related warning sign: an orange colour has been seen on a cylinder liner worn to its maximum limit. With no spare liner on board, that unit was stopped and the ship sailed on to the next port, where the liner was changed. I treat this orange colour as a sign that the liner will reach its wear limit soon, so check that a spare liner and the parts for a liner overhaul are on board. This is not confirmed.

Result#

I have no record of the final result. I don't know whether the crowns were reconditioned, renewed or kept in service, or whether the marks stopped after the fix.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in