Main engine liners: how often to do external wear scanning
EL-0163 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 30 Jun 2022
Source: /cases/el-0163
Notes#
External electronic scanning of main engine cylinder liners by an outside company is worth doing; what is not settled is how often, at least yearly or about every 5 years backed by onboard monitoring. This note sets out both approaches. It is general, with no engine maker, model, ship or wear readings.
Case for external measurement at least once a year
- Bad fuel can cause severe liner damage, which makes the measurements more useful.
- Inspecting the liners before dry dock tells the office the liner condition, so new liners can be ordered early.
- Liner readings from the crew are not always reliable. That argues for external measurements at least once a year.
Case for onboard monitoring, with a third party about every 5 years
- External scanning without pulling the piston gives useful data and helps to find abnormal liner wear.
- Depending too much on outside firms can cost the crew and the superintendents their skills.
- The ship can watch liner condition with its own methods:
- scavenge port inspections
- scrape-down oil analysis
- liner calibration when the piston is overhauled
- engine performance measurements
- On this approach, a third-party liner inspection about every 5 years is enough, sooner if the onboard reports are in doubt.
Not settled
The two approaches differ on frequency: external measurement at least yearly, or a third party about every 5 years plus regular onboard monitoring. I have not settled this.
What this note doesn't cover
- Engine maker or model, liner wear limits (in mm or % of bore), maker service letter references.
- Names of measuring equipment or service companies.
- Any real fault case or measured values.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.