MAN B&W two-stroke: limits for judging engine performance

Main EngineTurbochargerMAN B&W MC/MC-C, ME/ME-C/ME-B

Notes#

This is my checklist of practical limits for judging the performance of MAN B&W two-stroke main engines, both mechanical (MC/MC-C) and electronic (ME/ME-C/ME-B). I don't have the source of the limits or any MAN service letter references, and it is not tied to a specific fault case.

Cylinder pressures

Pmax

  • Balance: every cylinder should be within ±3 bar of the average Pmax of all cylinders. Outside this band, the engine is imbalanced.
  • If the average Pmax is more than 3 bar below the test-bed average, ignition timing is retarded. Possible causes:
    • poor fuel quality
    • VIT adjustment (MC)
    • fault in the HCU or tacho system (ME)
    • worn fuel equipment
    • fuel oil pressure
    • low Pcomp

Pcomp

  • Balance: every cylinder should be within ±3 bar of the average Pcomp.
  • If the average Pcomp is more than 3 bar below the test-bed average, suspect blow-by or loss of compression. Possible causes:
    • low scavenge air pressure
    • leaking exhaust valve
    • exhaust valve opening or closing stroke too small
    • HCU fault (ME)
    • blow-by past the piston rings
    • blow-by caused by the cylinder liners

Pi (mean indicated pressure)

  • Pi shows the load on each cylinder. Every cylinder should be within ±0.5 bar of the average Pi.
  • If the average Pi differs from the test-bed average by more than ±0.5 bar, the fuel equipment may be worn. Judge this together with the fuel index.

Pressure rise (Pmax − Pcomp)

  • Upper limit: about 35 bar on MC/MC-C, about 38–40 bar on ME/ME-C.
  • Lower limit: above about 75% load, the rise should not drop below about 20 bar. A smaller rise means poor performance and usually high fuel consumption.

Exhaust and turbocharger

ItemLimitIf outside
Exhaust temperature per cylinder outletwithin ±50 °C of averageAt ±60 °C slowdown is activated. Check cylinder pressures.
TC LO inlet pressure1.5–2.2 bar (see note)Higher pressure: blocked pipe or clogged orifice in the connection. Risk to TC bearings.
Turbine outlet back pressurebelow 300 mmWC at MCR (no funnel, economizer or scrubber), or below 150% of shop testRestriction in exhaust pipe after the turbine, or fouled nozzle ring. With an economizer: fouled gas passages are also possible. Judge together with exhaust temperatures.
  • Never adjust a cylinder based on exhaust temperature alone. Use the cylinder pressures instead.
  • Note: my original wording for TC LO inlet pressure was "should never go above 1.5–2.2 bar". This is unclear. It is probably the normal range, not a maximum.

Scavenge air and air cooler

ItemLimitIf outside
Scavenge air temperaturenormally max 45 °C, lower is better—
Air cooler pressure drop (air side)max 240 mmWC at MCR, or max 150% of shop testCooler air side is fouled. Clean it.
Air outlet temp − cooling water inlet tempmax 12–14 °CWater side may be fouled. Cooling efficiency is reduced.
Receiver temp − cooler outlet tempmax 2–4 °CSuspect blow-by in one or more cylinders. Check Pcomp per cylinder and piston underside temperatures.
Scavenge air pressure vs exhaust receiver pressurescavenge must always be higherMeasuring error, faulty U-tube manometer, or fouled turbine nozzle ring.
  • With a central cooling system, set the 3-way valve to 10 °C.
  • All U-tube manometers should be clean and working. In real life they rarely are, except maybe on a newbuilding.

How to determine engine load

  • ME-B/ME-C: read the load from the PMI system or from the MOP.
  • MC/MC-C: many people take the fuel pump index as the real load. This is a mistake. Use TC rpm or scavenge air pressure to find the load.
  • Always compare with test-bed values, not sea-trial values.

MOP load vs PMI load on ME engines

PMI power and MOP power do not always match. The reason:

  • The ECS calculates load from the fuel data typed into the fuel quality screen and compares this with shop-test values.
  • The ECS does not see fuel system problems, such as leaking injectors, faulty fuel pressure boosters, or mixing in the service tank.
  • So I check the MOP estimated load regularly: run the engine above 50% load and compare it with the PMI load. Keep the MOP estimate within ±2% of the PMI load.
  • Correct it with the fuel quality offset. Lower offset → higher estimated load. Higher offset → lower estimated load.
  • I treat the PMI as the most accurate system, because it reads crank angle from 2 angle encoders.

General trending advice

  1. Plot the propeller curve and the engine load curve. The engine should run on or a little below the reference curve.
  2. Compare SFOC against % CMCR over 60–110% CMCR.
  3. Trend Pmax, exhaust temperatures and SFOC every month.
  4. If Pmax goes up while power goes down, check for fuel index drift or loss of compression.
  5. Compare scavenge temperature with TC speed to find air-side fouling or leaks.
  6. Check control system feedbacks: fuel rack, timing, and exhaust valve actuator stroke (ME-B/C).
  7. Compare results with MAN reference data (CoCoS EDS templates or the ME Engine Performance File).

Not known

  • I have a related diagram only as an image; its content is not included here.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in