MAN B&W two-stroke: limits for judging engine performance
EL-0164 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 07 Feb 2023
Source: /cases/el-0164
Notes#
This is my checklist of practical limits for judging the performance of MAN B&W two-stroke main engines, both mechanical (MC/MC-C) and electronic (ME/ME-C/ME-B). I don't have the source of the limits or any MAN service letter references, and it is not tied to a specific fault case.
Cylinder pressures
Pmax
- Balance: every cylinder should be within
±3 barof the average Pmax of all cylinders. Outside this band, the engine is imbalanced. - If the average Pmax is more than
3 barbelow the test-bed average, ignition timing is retarded. Possible causes:- poor fuel quality
- VIT adjustment (MC)
- fault in the HCU or tacho system (ME)
- worn fuel equipment
- fuel oil pressure
- low Pcomp
Pcomp
- Balance: every cylinder should be within
±3 barof the average Pcomp. - If the average Pcomp is more than
3 barbelow the test-bed average, suspect blow-by or loss of compression. Possible causes:- low scavenge air pressure
- leaking exhaust valve
- exhaust valve opening or closing stroke too small
- HCU fault (ME)
- blow-by past the piston rings
- blow-by caused by the cylinder liners
Pi (mean indicated pressure)
- Pi shows the load on each cylinder. Every cylinder should be within
±0.5 barof the average Pi. - If the average Pi differs from the test-bed average by more than
±0.5 bar, the fuel equipment may be worn. Judge this together with the fuel index.
Pressure rise (Pmax − Pcomp)
- Upper limit: about
35 baron MC/MC-C, about38–40 baron ME/ME-C. - Lower limit: above about
75%load, the rise should not drop below about20 bar. A smaller rise means poor performance and usually high fuel consumption.
Exhaust and turbocharger
| Item | Limit | If outside |
|---|---|---|
| Exhaust temperature per cylinder outlet | within ±50 °C of average | At ±60 °C slowdown is activated. Check cylinder pressures. |
| TC LO inlet pressure | 1.5–2.2 bar (see note) | Higher pressure: blocked pipe or clogged orifice in the connection. Risk to TC bearings. |
| Turbine outlet back pressure | below 300 mmWC at MCR (no funnel, economizer or scrubber), or below 150% of shop test | Restriction in exhaust pipe after the turbine, or fouled nozzle ring. With an economizer: fouled gas passages are also possible. Judge together with exhaust temperatures. |
- Never adjust a cylinder based on exhaust temperature alone. Use the cylinder pressures instead.
- Note: my original wording for TC LO inlet pressure was "should never go above 1.5–2.2 bar". This is unclear. It is probably the normal range, not a maximum.
Scavenge air and air cooler
| Item | Limit | If outside |
|---|---|---|
| Scavenge air temperature | normally max 45 °C, lower is better | — |
| Air cooler pressure drop (air side) | max 240 mmWC at MCR, or max 150% of shop test | Cooler air side is fouled. Clean it. |
| Air outlet temp − cooling water inlet temp | max 12–14 °C | Water side may be fouled. Cooling efficiency is reduced. |
| Receiver temp − cooler outlet temp | max 2–4 °C | Suspect blow-by in one or more cylinders. Check Pcomp per cylinder and piston underside temperatures. |
| Scavenge air pressure vs exhaust receiver pressure | scavenge must always be higher | Measuring error, faulty U-tube manometer, or fouled turbine nozzle ring. |
- With a central cooling system, set the 3-way valve to
10 °C. - All U-tube manometers should be clean and working. In real life they rarely are, except maybe on a newbuilding.
How to determine engine load
- ME-B/ME-C: read the load from the PMI system or from the MOP.
- MC/MC-C: many people take the fuel pump index as the real load. This is a mistake. Use TC rpm or scavenge air pressure to find the load.
- Always compare with test-bed values, not sea-trial values.
MOP load vs PMI load on ME engines
PMI power and MOP power do not always match. The reason:
- The ECS calculates load from the fuel data typed into the fuel quality screen and compares this with shop-test values.
- The ECS does not see fuel system problems, such as leaking injectors, faulty fuel pressure boosters, or mixing in the service tank.
- So I check the MOP estimated load regularly: run the engine above
50%load and compare it with the PMI load. Keep the MOP estimate within±2%of the PMI load. - Correct it with the fuel quality offset. Lower offset → higher estimated load. Higher offset → lower estimated load.
- I treat the PMI as the most accurate system, because it reads crank angle from 2 angle encoders.
General trending advice
- Plot the propeller curve and the engine load curve. The engine should run on or a little below the reference curve.
- Compare SFOC against % CMCR over
60–110%CMCR. - Trend Pmax, exhaust temperatures and SFOC every month.
- If Pmax goes up while power goes down, check for fuel index drift or loss of compression.
- Compare scavenge temperature with TC speed to find air-side fouling or leaks.
- Check control system feedbacks: fuel rack, timing, and exhaust valve actuator stroke (ME-B/C).
- Compare results with MAN reference data (CoCoS EDS templates or the ME Engine Performance File).
Not known
- I have a related diagram only as an image; its content is not included here.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.