MAN B&W ME-C on VLSFO: which cylinder oil BN to use
EL-0166 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 14 Oct 2022
Source: /cases/el-0166
Notes#
There is no single right cylinder oil BN for MAN B&W ME-C two-stroke engines burning VLSFO (0.5 % sulphur): results depend on the engine and on how it is run. These are my notes from about three years (2022 to 2025) of fleet experience with BN40 to BN100; it is not one fault case.
My fleet trials
| BN tried | What I saw |
|---|---|
| BN40 | Liner and ring scuffing, more than one time |
| BN70 | No problems, but residual BN in the scavenge drain was too high. MAN says too much residual BN can polish the liner. |
| BN57 | About 2 years in service. No problems. Good scrape-down results. |
Experience from other fleets
The results I have seen elsewhere do not agree with each other:
- BN40, BN70 and BN100 over 2-3 years, sometimes mixed: no big difference, no scuffing, scrape-down results about the same. That fleet plans to use mostly BN40.
- Heavier grade as base oil: one fleet once ran BN40 ("540") on all engines. For the last year it has used BN70 to BN100 ("570" to "5100") as the base oil, changing to BN40 from time to time. The feed rate follows the scrape-down results:
- With the heavier grade, the feed rate may go down.
- With the lighter grade, the feed rate may go up.
- BN70-BN100 on VLSFO: worked well, with low Fe and no deposits, but higher residual BN.
- Category II BN40 with good detergency (2023): good results. Several suppliers now sell Category II BN40 oils.
- BN40 as standard on all vessels (2025):
- Scrape-down analysis every week, on Friday.
- Normal drain Fe is
15-25 ppm. - If Fe goes over
100 ppm, the cylinder oil feed rate is raised. - On "small-bore" engines, BN100 is kept on board as a corrective oil. Small-bore is defined there by BMEP below
60 bar, not by bore size (this is the figure as I have it; it looks unusual to me). BN100 is used 2-3 times a year, mostly to clear carbon build-up between the ring lands.
MAN guidance
- MAN first recommended BN40 (Category I oils) for VLSFO.
- Later MAN advised changing between high-BN and low-BN oil every week (Service Letter SL2019-671/JAP). In practice the weekly change is hard to do on board.
- Advice I have from a MAN engineer: the lower the Fe in the drain oil, the better.
What I judge first
- Cleanliness of the piston crown top land and ring lands (this shows oil detergency).
- Iron (Fe) content in the scrape-down oil.
There is no fixed rule. I inspect the scavenge ports often and analyse the drain oil often. The right BN also depends on:
- The engine Mark. Engines with high firing pressure (Mark 8 and later) are more sensitive and need a higher-BN oil.
- The operating profile, for example low load and short voyages.
Points that keep coming back
- Scrape-down (scavenge drain) analysis is the main tool. Watch Fe and residual BN.
- Scavenge port inspection shows ring, liner and land condition.
- Too low a BN may give scuffing on some engines. Too high a BN may give high residual BN and a risk of liner polishing.
- Detergency of the oil matters, not only the BN.
What this note doesn't cover
- Engine models, bore sizes, feed rates in g/kWh and ACC factor settings.
- Residual BN limits in numbers, and oil brands (I have only the 540/570/5100 grade names).
- Any root-cause check of the BN40 scuffing.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.