MAN B&W main engine in heavy weather: torque vs rpm governor mode
EL-0178 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 04 Feb 2023
Source: /cases/el-0178
Notes#
To protect the main engine liners and piston rings in heavy weather, I reduce RPM and choose the governor mode with care: on ME-B and ME-C engines that means weighing Torque mode against RPM mode. This note covers both modes and the risks of each.
Basic measures
- Use the engine maker's manual as the first reference.
- Reduce engine RPM when the sea is rough.
- On ME-B and ME-C engines, one option is to change the governor from RPM mode to Torque mode.
- On older MC engines, use the rough sea mode that the engine manual describes.
What the governor modes do
This is a general description, not a quote from a MAN service letter.
| Mode | How it works |
|---|---|
| Torque mode | MAN's default governor setting on ME-C engines. It is used when the manoeuvring order is FULL or above. The governor does not hold speed exactly; speed may move within a limited range. In return, the torque is more even and the engine uses less fuel. |
| RPM mode | The older default on ME engines. The target is a constant speed. To hold the ordered RPM, the governor must keep changing the load. The result is a fuel index that does not stay still. |
The manual does not fully explain the change between RPM and Torque mode. The MOP panel display changes when the system goes from RPM to Torque mode; I don't have details of what changes.
The case against Torque mode in rough seas
- The ME-B and ME-C design intends torque mode as the normal running mode at all times. SFOC is lowest in this mode.
- Torque control and Index control work the same way. The system holds the fuel index and lets it move only a little.
- With the fuel index held, engine speed is free to move. In rough seas this means large RPM swings, so the chance of overspeed is higher.
- Because of this, the control software leaves torque or index control and goes to RPM control by itself when engine speed is unsteady.
- My rule of thumb: select torque or index control for performance reports. This keeps Pi (mean indicated pressure) as even as possible during the readings.
- In my service experience, torque or index control often causes disagreement between the Chief Engineer and the Master. At sea, the two normally agree on one RPM for the passage, but in torque or index control the RPM never stays fixed.
Open point
I have not settled which mode is better in heavy weather. Torque mode gives more even torque, but RPM fluctuates, overspeed risk goes up, and the software falls back to RPM control on its own. Check the engine maker's manual for your engine.
What this note doesn't cover
- Figures for RPM or load reduction, overspeed or shutdown setpoints, and liner temperature limits.
- Cylinder lube oil feed rate or ACC changes, and scavenge port or liner inspection after heavy weather.
- The name of the automatic switch function or how to set it.
- MAN service letter numbers, or any real damage case.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.