Aft stern tube bearing wiped by partial propeller immersion

Propulsion & Thrusters

Notes#

Running with the propeller not fully immersed puts off-centre thrust on the shaft, which edge-loads the aft stern tube bearing and can wipe its white metal within minutes. My main reference is DNV GL Technical and Regulatory News No. 01/2017 (January 2017), "Incomplete propeller immersion - risk of propeller shaft bearing damage". DNV GL names partial immersion as a suspected contributing factor, not the only cause. Its main points:

  • Trend. DNV GL saw more and more damage to aft propeller shaft bearings. It was not limited to one ship type. It was linked to ships that ran with draft or loading limits and took no steps to limit RPM or power.
  • Speed of damage. Most damage was reported to grow quickly: typically from a few minutes up to about one hour.
  • What was found. White metal wiped in the aft part of the bearing. This shows that the hydrodynamic oil film was fully or partly lost.
  • Warning sign. Bearing temperature rises when the shaft touches the bearing. In most cases the rise is exponential. In one case the ship kept running past the alarm point (normally 65 °C). The bearing was damaged, even though the temperature rose more slowly in that case.
  • Consequences.
    • Full or partial loss of main propulsion.
    • Damage to the propeller shaft itself if steel touches steel.
    • Costly repairs that take a long time.
    • Long running with partial immersion, even with no failure at once, adds a risk of bearing fatigue failure. The cause is cyclic loading and shear forces.
  • What keeps the oil film. RPM, shaft diameter, oil viscosity, bearing load, and the effective contact area between shaft and bearing. The contact area also sets the local surface pressure.
  • Design basis. Class rules assume a fully immersed propeller. Design margins allow for some uneven propeller loading only, for example an uneven wake or blade tips near the surface.

Mechanism (from the notice):

  1. With the propeller partly out of the water, thrust does not act on the shaft centre line.
  2. This off-centre thrust gives a downward bending moment on the shaft.
  3. The relative slope (angular misalignment) at the aft bearing increases.
  4. The shaft bears on the aft edge of the bearing (edge loading).
  5. Contact area gets smaller and local surface pressure rises steeply.
  6. The oil film breaks down and the bearing wipes.

The extra bending moment depends on how much of the propeller is out of the water, and on RPM and power. The moment is proportional to thrust. Thrust is proportional to RPM squared. So the risk rises steeply with RPM.

Advice to operators (from the notice):

  1. Make sure the propeller is fully immersed.
  2. Include this in the onboard operating procedures and make crews aware of the risk.
  3. Define precautions for exceptional conditions.
  4. When partial immersion cannot be avoided (shallow water, light condition when going into dry dock, ballast exchange at sea), carry out a design/risk assessment and take measures to reduce the risk:
    • lower RPM and power
    • limit rudder angles
    • use tugs
  5. Other effects, such as changes in torsional vibration behaviour, also need attention. The notice does not cover them.

Where I see it in practice. In my experience, most stern tube bearing damage happens in two situations:

  • entering or leaving a shipyard with the main engine running and the propeller not fully immersed because of draft limits;
  • stern slamming and propeller racing in heavy weather.

What this note doesn't cover. A real damage case with readings; the bearing type and lubrication type (oil or water), apart from white metal; any RPM limit, immersion ratio or repair method.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in