Stern tube oil: EAL vs mineral oil, downsides beyond price
EL-0192 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 24 Jun 2022
Source: /cases/el-0192
Notes#
Beyond its higher price, EAL (bio, biodegradable) stern tube oil has two risks compared with mineral oil: some EAL oils hold a weaker oil film under heavy load, and EAL oil is harmed by water ingress. This is my own view.
- Some EAL oils lubricate less well. Not every EAL oil has poor lubricating properties, but some do.
- The oil film can be lost. With such an oil, the film may not be strong enough under heavy load. The risk is at low shaft RPM, during manoeuvring, and when the stern slams in heavy weather. The shaft and the stern tube bearing can then touch metal to metal.
- Water harms EAL oil. If water gets into the stern tube, the oil can form an emulsion and then break down. The bearing can then fail, and the ship can be left without propulsion.
- My preferred design. I think mineral oil with an air-type stern tube seal is the safest choice and also the best for the environment.
- The main point. If a loaded tanker of about
300,000 dwtloses propulsion in heavy seas, the result is an environmental disaster, whether the stern tube oil is biodegradable or not.
What this note doesn't cover:
- Vessel, oil brand or EAL type (for example synthetic ester or PAG), or seal and bearing makers.
- A real failure case or readings.
- Water content limits or oil analysis intervals.
- Maker service letters or class notices.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.