Two-stroke liner and ring scuffing: causes, symptoms and monitoring
EL-0195 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 21 Mar 2023
Source: /cases/el-0195
Notes#
Scuffing is heavy adhesive wear of cylinder liners and piston rings in two-stroke engines that starts when the oil film breaks down, and it usually comes from several factors acting together. These notes are built around the CIMAC guideline "The causes of scuffing and actions to prevent scuffing in two-stroke engines" (March 2023), written by CIMAC Working Group 8 (Marine Lubricants), which I find cautious and well documented. They are general and not tied to one engine maker, model or ship case.
What scuffing is. A type of heavy adhesive wear on lubricated sliding surfaces, which happens when the oil film has broken down or failed.
Mechanism
- Once the oil film breaks down, wear speeds up very fast. Liners and piston rings can be damaged within a few days.
- At TDC the piston speed is zero, so lubrication there is boundary lubrication. While the piston moves in the liner, lubrication is hydrodynamic.
Symptoms and monitoring. When scuffing happens, liner temperatures behave like this:
- Liner wall temperatures go up and down quickly and often.
- The general level of liner temperature goes up.
Fixed temperature alarms are hard to use for this. The limits must be changed again and again, and normal temperature swings that have nothing to do with scuffing give false alarms. I watch the trend and the pattern of fluctuation in liner temperatures, not only a fixed alarm limit. I don't have temperature values or alarm settings to give.
Causes linked to fuel. Scuffing has been linked partly to the use of very low sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO) in older engines, with higher density properties and more stress on engine parts. Other factors:
- Red deposits.
- Poor fuel handling during the changeover to VLSFO.
- Waste from the fuel system being flushed through the engine.
Keep to the recommended maintenance programme to avoid liner wear and damage. The industry has now adapted to VLSFO. Even so, scuffing normally comes from several factors acting at the same time, and I think blaming VLSFO alone is wrong. A related reference is the Chevron paper "Scuffing And Red Deposits After Fuel Transition"; I have not summarised it here.
What this note doesn't cover. A real damage case, engine type, running hours, cylinder oil feed rate, BN, oil type, temperature readings, alarm settings, inspection findings or corrective actions. Neither referenced document is summarised.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.