Generator con-rod seizes and holes the block: oil run far past interval (Ocean Navigator)

Auxiliary EngineFire & SafetyCaterpillar 3516BER fire alarm, AE2 low LO pressure and oil filter plugged, blackout

Contents
  1. What happened
  2. Diagnosis
  3. Root cause
  4. Timeline / response
  5. Lessons
  6. Comments · 0

What happened#

AE2 on a coastal cruise ship (Caterpillar 3516B, 1,800 rpm) had run its LO for more than 5,000 h and its filter elements for 3,329 h. Both should be changed at 1,000 h (LO longer only under Caterpillar's own analysis programme; the ship used a third-party lab). It also needed far more top-up oil than its twin.

The ship was alongside with 210 on board. AE2 was alone on load at about 40%. The 3/E found a small LO leak from a crankcase door, with a door bolt turning loose. As he and a motorman sat beside the engine to tighten it, the No. 13 con-rod broke away and holed the block. Oil mist vented out and caught fire. AE2 tripped and the ship blacked out. The motorman got burns on about 40% of his body. Damage was about $2.4 million.

Hole in the AE2 block where the No. 13 con-rod came out (left) and cylinder layout (right). Photo and graphic: NTSB
Hole in the AE2 block where the No. 13 con-rod came out (left) and cylinder layout (right). Photo and graphic: NTSB

Diagnosis#

  • Filters 3× past interval: limits are 1,000 h, 15 psi dP or every oil change. After the failure the ECM held an oil filter restriction warning, and "oil filter plugged" alarmed as the engine failed. No AE2 alarms before that.
  • Top-up: AE2 took 37 gal in September and 42 gal in October. AE1, at similar load, took about 5 gal.
  • Oil analysis looked fine. The 24 Sept sample was within tolerances; 24 July was "suitable for further service". After the failure: Al 17 ppm (abnormal), Fe up from 23 to 37 ppm, Pb and Sn up.
  • Caterpillar found debris damage, including large particles, and poor oil film on the main and rod bearings, with heavy cavitation erosion on the rod bearings.
  • No. 13/14 crankpin severely damaged, both counterweights torn off. No OMD, no bearing temperature monitoring.
No. 13 piston and con-rod (left) and the No. 13 rod bearing shells (right). Photo: NTSB
No. 13 piston and con-rod (left) and the No. 13 rod bearing shells (right). Photo: NTSB

Root cause#

Debris in the LO likely scored the bearings' inner (typically aluminium-alloy) layer. Clearances would have grown, oil pressure and film were lost, and the No. 13 con-rod seized and broke away, rupturing the block. Hot atomised oil vented through the damaged covers and ignited on hot components inside the engine.

How the debris got in is unknown. Old oil holds more dirt, and a clogged element keeps its bypass valve open. The NTSB says the debris was possibly due to running the LO and filters past the maker's intervals.

Timeline / response#

TimeEvent
~07:08AE1 stopped after exhaust high-temperature alarms.
—3/E finds LO leak and loose crankcase door bolt on AE2.
07:09:55ER fire alarm. AE2 has holed the block.
07:10:06AE2 low LO pressure and oil filter plugged.
07:10:12AE2 trips on low LO pressure. Blackout, emergency generator on.
—C/E closes QCVs. Fans, dampers and doors shut.
07:16General alarm, muster.
07:21Fire team in BA enters ER.
07:41Only smoke found. Fire out by itself.

Lessons#

  1. Change LO and filter elements on hours. A "normal" lab result does not justify running oil five times past interval.
  2. Treat a filter-restriction alarm or high dP as urgent. It can mean the bypass valve is open and unfiltered oil is reaching the bearings.
  3. Compare top-up rates between sister engines. 79 gal against 5 gal needs an investigation now.
  4. Trend Fe, Al, Pb, Sn and Cu over time. This oil was rated fit for service, yet the bearings had large-particle debris damage.
  5. Know and drill the ER shutoffs. Closing QCVs, fans, dampers and doors starved this fire. Train often on FO, LO and ventilation shutoffs.
  6. After a bearing failure, open up the sister engine. One AE1 rod bearing was sampled, and its condition led to replacing all of them.

Source: NTSB report MIR-25-13 — Diesel Generator Engine Failure aboard Passenger Vessel Ocean Navigator.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in