When to replace a radar magnetron
EL-0187 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 24 Jun 2022
Source: /cases/el-0187
Notes#
I replace X-band and S-band radar magnetrons on condition (magnetron current and performance tests), not on running hours alone, and I always keep a spare on board. The maker's hour interval is a prompt to check, not a hard limit.
Two approaches
- Replace at the interval the maker recommends.
- Keep the magnetron running until a problem appears.
I prefer the second, on condition that a spare magnetron is always on board.
Maker interval and real life
- Makers usually recommend replacement at about
4,000 hof running time. At this point the radar shows a replacement reminder on the screen. - In my experience, a magnetron can last about
8,000–10,000 h. - I keep using the magnetron past the maker's interval as long as performance tests and magnetron current stay inside the maker's limits, and replace it when performance drops.
- Always keep a spare set of magnetrons on board.
Wear limit by magnetron current
- Measure the magnetron current at the longest pulse length. If it is down to about half of the as-new value, the magnetron is at the end of its life.
- This rule needs a reference: the current of the same magnetron when new, at the longest pulse length.
Inspections (third-party or class)
- For an inspection, the radar is acceptable if it meets IMO Resolution MSC.192(79), especially Table 2 of that resolution.
- In my view, running hours of the magnetron, or of any other part, do not matter for the inspection; only radar performance counts. A yearly car test does not depend on how long ago the engine oil was changed.
Limits of this information
- The half-current rule and the
8,000–10,000 hlife come from experience, not from a radar maker. - I don't have actual magnetron current values in
mA, and I have not specified which performance test (for example, a performance monitor or tuning indicator). - What this note doesn't cover: magnetron warm-up or ageing after replacement, high-voltage or radiation safety, and maker service letters. Follow the maker's manual for these.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.