Log inJoin

Two-stroke load diagram: why the same mep is overload at low rpm

Main EngineMAN B&W

Notes#

On a MAN B&W two-stroke load diagram, the same mep that is fine at high RPM counts as overload at low RPM because the torque limit is set mainly by the thermal load of engine components, with weak air charging at low load also playing a part. For example, on the diagram 90 % mep is acceptable at 95 % RPM but not at 75 % RPM: the low-RPM point is past the overload (torque) limit, the higher-RPM point is inside it.

What MAN says.

  • In MAN's definition, the torque limit line is the speed/torque limit for continuous running.
  • MAN says this limit is defined mainly by the thermal load of the engine components. The MAN wording I have does not mention bearings.

Air charging and efficiency.

  • The engine is more efficient at higher load, closer to NCR.
  • Combustion at low load is not ideal. The main cause is weak air charging: the turbocharger supplies less scavenge air at low load.
  • A typical two-stroke SFOC curve shows this, with higher SFOC (g/kWh) at low load.
  • Older engines had fuel valve trouble at low load; newer designs no longer have this problem.

Bearing theory (my own, not confirmed).

  • I thought the limit could come from hydrodynamic lubrication of the bearings: at higher RPM the oil film between journal and bearing gets thicker, so the bearings can carry higher firing loads.
  • I also wondered whether the crosshead bearing, which only swings back and forth, might be the weak point instead of the main bearings.
  • I have not confirmed this and found very little information on it.

Running above the torque limit on ME (electronic) engines. On MAN electronic engines the ECS can let the engine exceed the torque limit for a short time, through two functions:

  1. DLF.
    • The ECS works out the air mass in each cylinder before every firing.
    • From that air mass, it sets the largest fuel amount that still keeps an acceptable minimum air excess ratio.
    • After about 30 min of DLF running, the engine components need to cool. The ECS then slowly brings the limits back to the normal fuel index limiter.
  2. AWC (Adverse Weather Condition functionality, "upcoming" when I wrote this).
    • More fuel goes into the cylinder, so the engine gives more torque.
    • Injection timing is moved later. This keeps peak pressure and combustion temperature down.
    • Because of this, piston crown, exhaust valve, cylinder liner and cylinder cover stay below the temperatures they reach at SMCR.
    • The cost is about 3-4 % higher SFOC than running on the normal torque limit curve.

Reference: MAN circular "Adverse weather condition functionality and minimum propulsion power" (PDF). I don't have its document number.

What this note doesn't cover: engine model or bore, real readings, or a document number.

Comments · 0

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment, vote and confirm fixes.Sign in