Fuel treatment chemicals: why engine makers prefer good fuel management
EL-0157 · Knowledge · rating 0 · occurred 11 Jul 2022
Source: /cases/el-0157
Notes#
The big makers of main and generator engines prefer good fuel management to fuel treatment chemicals; they have not confirmed the claimed benefits of additives. The one exception I make is a lubricity additive for MGO and other distillates. This note covers whether these chemicals change combustion and whether the fuel analysis should decide dosing.
The products and the claims
- After the 2020 global sulphur cap, many fuel additive products came onto the market.
- Suppliers claim better combustion, lower fuel consumption, more stable fuel and longer time between overhauls.
- As far as I know, the big engine makers say they have not confirmed these benefits, either in shop tests or in service. I can't name a specific maker.
What the makers ask for instead
- Good, complete purification.
- As little mixing of different bunkers as possible.
- Regular draining of the settling and service tanks.
- Fuel kept inside the ISO specification limits (I don't have the standard number to hand).
Insurance warning
- Additives may change the result of an investigation when there is an insurance claim about fuel problems. This may also lead to disputes with the hull and machinery underwriters.
How I use them, by fuel type
| Fuel | Chemicals |
|---|---|
| MGO and other distillates | Lubricity chemicals may help and can usually be used without problems. I recommend a lubricity additive for MGO, most of all when the fuel test report gives a low-lubricity alert. |
| HFO and VLSFO | Conditioning chemicals are generally not recommended. |
What this note doesn't cover
- A real engine fault or case, or confirmed results from any additive.
- Product, brand or engine maker names, and maker service letters.
- Lubricity values (for example wear scar diameter) and dosing rates.
Comments · 0
No comments yet.